When I first started vaping, like so many people, I thought that if it didn't taste like tobacco, I didn't want anything to do with it. Boy, was that a wrong assumption. Now, I can't imagine putting something in my PV that tastes like tobacco. My favorite so far is cotton candy, and I also like caramel, honeysuckle, apple, and a bunch of other ones. I mix my own juice, so I have about 15-20 different flavors I cycle through. My point is, don't spend too much time trying to match the flavor of your pipe. For one, you most likely never will. For two, there are a bazillion flavor choices out there. Be adventurous!